Where Halloween Lives Beyond October

How to Make Layered Vintage Inspired Halloween Bookmarks | Step-By-Step DIY

Vintage Inspired Halloween Bookmarks
Vintage Inspired Halloween Bookmarks

A Modest Addition to Your Haunted Library

I just finished framing a recent haunted acquisition – a vintage Halloween postcard – now lurking over my shoulder in the office, and I can already feel the obsession creeping in. This makes only the third Halloween postcard in our collection, which is exactly the kind of “harmless start” that spirals into a full-blown vintage ephemera hunt. You know how it goes – one minute you’re admiring the artwork, the next you’re chasing down ghostly paper relics like they owe you something.

This particular piece – an unsigned Ellen Clapsaddle – leans delightfully strange. The verse reads:

Halloween Greetings
“An’ the Gobble-uns’ll git you
If you don’t watch out!”

Ellen Clapsaddle Halloween postcard

Charming, right? Nothing says seasonal cheer like a vague threat from something lurking just out of sight. These “Gobble-uns” sound less like mischief-makers and more like something you’d rather not meet in a dark hallway. Yikes!

Despite the ominous warning, my curiosity got the best of me. I started digging into more of these eerie little verses because vintage Halloween poetry has a way of sticking to your bones, and I quickly found myself plotting how to weave them into future projects.

As fate would have it, I recently picked up a copy of The Grave Below by Patrick Hansma. Patrick – can I call him Patrick? – is an author, rare book dealer, and forensic pathologist. That’s got to be a recipe for a good read, don’t you think?

The Grave Below by Patrick Hansma

The premise alone sealed the deal: a 16th-century Puritan vampire colliding with a modern-day grave robber, tangled up in a witch hunt while detectives chase a string of murders. It’s exactly the kind of story that deserves something better than a scrap of paper marking your place. In other words, before I dive into the grave, I need the proper bookmark with a bit of haunted personality.

So, if you enjoy seasonal reads, nostalgic Halloween vibes, and adding a hauntingly handmade touch to your ghost stories, this project is a perfect fit.

Amassing Materials for Vintage Inspired Halloween Bookmarks

A Quick Raid of the Creepy Craft Cabinet

For this project, we will need:

Cardstock – 3 colors per bookmark
Printer (not shown)
Cutting machine – I’m using the Cricut Maker
Adhesive
Tassel or ribbon
Embellishments (optional)

Supplies to make vintage inspired Halloween bookmarks

We will also need the Vintage Halloween Poetry Bookmark Set files from the Haunted Library. Your download includes everything needed to create both vintage inspired Halloween bookmark designs.

Join the Haunted Library at Making Make Believe for Free Templates

The verses of Halloween poetry I selected for these bookmarks come from two old Halloween postcards, one by Gibson Art Company and one by George C. Whitney.

Eerily Equipped – Machine Cutting

Spooky Size It

After downloading the Vintage Halloween Poetry Bookmark Set, upload it to your favorite design software. I’m using Cricut Design Space.

The default measurements for the bookmarks should be 2” x 7” (sometimes Design Space chooses to size differently). To resize the bookmarks, keep the layers grouped and adjust the size as desired.

Size as desired in Cricut Design Space

Proper Papers

Before you begin cutting, select a colored cardstock for each layer. Be sure to consider that the center layer color will host the text, so a lighter paper color is a good choice. If you prefer a different text color, you can change it via the Color Swatch in the Top Bar Menu.

Change text color in the Color Swatch menu

Operation Print Then Cut

Once you have the project sized correctly, ungroup the layers. Select the text from the Layers Panel and and change it from Basic Cut to Print Then Cut from the Operation drop-down menu.

If you skip this step, the machine will cut out each tiny letter, which is terrifying.

Change text to Print Then Cut in the Operations drop-down menu

Flattened

Next, select the text and middle layer in the Layers Panel, and choose Flatten. This will attach the text to the center layer.

Select text and middle layer and flatten
Text and middle layer and flattened for cutting

Cut It Out

Follow the prompts on the screen and cut out each layer. Note that when cutting the Print Then Cut layer containing the text, set the Bleed to off.

Vintage inspired Halloween bookmark layers cut out

Assembling the Layers (Bring It All Together)

The Glue That Sticks

To assemble the layers, I like to use a fine liquid glue. My favorite is Bearly Art Precision Craft Glue, but I have misplaced the fine tip (imagine that!), so I’m using AdTech Fine Liquid Glue, which also works very well.

Other adhesives, such as double sided tape rollers, are also effective.  I like to use a bit of both glues but you pick your poison that works best for you.

Labyrinth of Layers

To begin, spread adhesive on the backside of the top layer. Then, aligning the edges and cutouts, place this layer on top of the center layer that contains the text.

Immediately clean up any adhesive that has wormed its way into the text or cutout areas.

Apply adhesive to back of top layer
Align top layer onto middle layer

Next, spread adhesive on the back of your stacked layers, align the edges, and place the stack on top of the bottom layer.

Glue top with middle stack to bottom layer

Finishing Touches For Vintage Inspired Halloween Bookmarks

Refined With Ribbon

For some frightfully fun flair, add some embellishments to your bookmark. I like to use a velvet ribbon or a handmade tassel paired with a chilling charm.

Add a ribbon and charm to bookmark

Timeless Tassle | Step-by-Step

You can craft a tassel easily with some embroidery floss and a rectangle cut from cardboard.

Step 1: Tassel With A Tail

First, cut a piece of cardboard to the length of the tassel you’d like to make. Leave a tail of floss that extends beyond the top of the cardboard, then begin wrapping your floss.

Begin wrapping floss onto cardboard for tassel

Step 2: Wrap Like A Mummy

Continue wrapping the floss until your tassel is the thickness you desire. Then cut the floss even with the bottom of your cardboard.

Continue wrapping

Step 3: Tie A Killer Knot

Cut a 12” to 15” length of floss, slip it between the wrapped floss and the cardboard, and tie a tight knot.

Tie off top of floss wrap

Step 4: Make The Cut

Slide the floss off the cardboard, slip your scissors into the bottom loops, and cut.

Remove floss from board and cut bottom of loop

Step 5: Snug As A Bug

Cut a 8” to 10” length of floss and tie it snuggly around the top, then tuck the ends into the body of the tassel.

Tie off the top of the tassel

Step 6: Tastefully Executed Trim

Finally, trim the tassel so the ends are even.

Trim the tassel ends evenly

Step 7: Fearsome Fluffing

For a fluffier tassel, gently “comb” out the floss with a wig brush or fine comb, then tie it onto the Halloween bookmark.

Blend the floss strands with a brush
Attach tassel to bookmark

Otherworldly Options

If making a treasure trove of tassels is in your future, you can invest in a tool like the Clover Tassel Maker, available in large or small sizes. This is a handy little gadget that I used to make our Bride and Groom Yarn Ghosts.

Last Spooky Looks

Tucking Into Your Next Read

All that’s left is to pair your vintage inspired Halloween bookmark with your favorite ghost story.

Vintage Inspired Halloween Bookmark
Vintage Inspired Halloween Bookmark

Until next time – stay spooky.

Free templates & patterns

130+ freebies are waiting in the Haunted Library

Templates, patterns and printables for every project on the blog.

Marsha
Your haunted host

Marsha

Counting down to Halloween since the 1970s. I create, style and celebrate all things costume and Halloween, all year round.

You May Also Like
About Me
Marsha

Hi, I’m Marsha

Welcome to my world of Halloween Ever After, where I create, style, and celebrate all things costume and Halloween.

Find Something Fun
Affiliate Disclosure

Within these haunted pages lie affiliate links to curious and captivating finds I love. If you make a purchase through them, I may earn a modest commission (think fun-size candy bar), which helps keep the Halloween magic alive. No extra cost to you – cross my batty heart.

Bearly Art Precision Craft Glue
A Making Make Believe favorite!
Buy Now
Bride and Groom Yarn Ghosts

I Do!

A Ghostly DIY

Make Me!

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Black vodka martini on a Halloween party tablescape

It's Official!

We're Haunt Friends

Check your email for the Haunted Library password.

 

Don’t miss a moment of the mischief.

Add hello@halloweeneverafter.com to your address book.

The magic happens right here in my studio and office. When you step inside my creative space, you’ll find an ever expanding gallery wall overflowing with original spooky art and classic Halloween LPs, right alongside a haunted cabinet packed to the brim with vintage curiosities.

It’s under the watchful eyes of these retro treasures that I design and craft.

We Have Room

For One More

Join us and get access to our Haunted Library stocked with templates, printables, cut files, and exclusive content. Plus, you’ll receive Eerie Emails just for our subscribers.

*Stay as long as you like. Unsubscribe at any time.