Where Halloween Lives Beyond October

The Best Vintage Halloween Treasures Added to My Collection

Haunted Vintage Halloween Treasures Collage
Haunted Vintage Halloween Treasures Collage

Halloween Treasure Hunting

Some of my projects start with a simple idea that quickly spirals into a full-blown obsession, and this latest project has been just that. The plan was to craft a few quick vintage-inspired ornaments – swiftly moving through all the steps of pattern designing, testing, creating, and adding them to the shop. Unfortunately, the ghosts of Halloween ambition had other ideas.

The original plan for three ornaments has now evolved into six, because apparently I’m incapable of leaving well enough alone once the spooky inspiration starts flowing. The original vision was entirely fabric-based, but somewhere along the way, paper and felt crept into the madness. Then came the testing phase – which was supposed to be straightforward until certain dreadful details refused to cooperate, forcing redesigns, revisions, and at least a few dramatic moments spent questioning my creative sanity while buried beneath a pile of creepy craft supplies.

And – I’ve loved every minute of it. There’s something strangely satisfying about chasing that perfect blend of vintage Halloween charm and eerie little details, even when the creative process leaves my spooky studio in complete disarray. Thankfully, the finish line is in sight, and I’m excited to soon bring them into the shop.

Halloween ornaments sneak peek
Halloween Ornaments Sneak Peek

Since the collection still needs a bit more time in the crypt before it’s fully ready, I figured now was the perfect excuse to share a few newly acquired haunted treasures instead. So if you’re in the mood for vintage Halloween goodness, curious finds, and a little seasonal inspiration, settle in and take a peek at what’s new at my haunted house.

Frightful Facebook Marketplace

Tiny Treats

A recent stroll through Facebook Marketplace yielded this ghoulish little group of goodies – a (1970s?) Russ black cat pin, four skull cake picks, and two Hep Cat cake toppers. We have amassed quite a large collection of dreadful cake decor, so I was quick to snap these up.

Vintage Halloween cake picks, toppers, and pin

These tiny treats are a simple and affordable way to incorporate vintage pieces into your spooky designs. And, if you are new to collecting or lack space, these are perfect as they are very affordable and can be displayed without taking up too much room.  

Our stash of creepy cake accouterments is currently stored in glass jars, but I’m preparing some shadow boxes so we can put them on display.

Peculiar Plate Procurement

Goblins Galore

Another Facebook Marketplace find was a set of four plates featuring frightfully fun costumed kiddos. The pattern Goblins by Ursula Dodge was released by Signature Housewares Incorporated in 2000.

Halloween plates - Goblins by Ursula Dodge

Since my childhood dates back to the 60s, 70s, and 80s, plates from 2000 don’t seem that old to me, but they are officially vintage. I think these will make for a creepy-cute display come Halloween season or an eerily excellent gift when loaded up with Halloween treats.

Plastic Popcorn – Don’t Eat That!

I’m Melting!

Speaking of childhood, Facebook Marketplace strikes yet again with two melted plastic, aka plastic popcorn, Halloween decorations. I recall these in my classroom when I was in elementary school. These whimsically weird decorations were often hung in the windows or near the bulletin board during spooky season.

Accidentally invented in the 1950s by The Kage Company in Manchester, Connecticut, these weirdly wonderful decorations were created for every holiday, and some are quite elusive.

Vintage melted plastic popcorn witch, Peter Pumpkin Jack o'lantern, and skull

We have two Jack O’Lanterns (aka Peter Pumpkin) in our collection, and we’re excited to finally find the skull and the witch, but there are many other designs we have yet to capture.

Nightmarish Napkins

Petrifying Paper

Another inexpensive find for the collector is Halloween napkins. This trio was buried under a pile of other assorted papers on an antique store shelf and looked to have been forgotten. After fishing them out of the heap, they now await a frame for display.

Vintage Halloween napkins

And, speaking of forgotten, the orange napkin featuring the witch and cat is already in our collection and is framed on the wall above my chair in the office. Now we have two in our collection. Sorry – not sorry.

Ghostly Reads

Childhood Revisited

A quick pop into the Goodwill yielded this find from my childhood – The Ghost of Windy Hill by Clyde Robert Bulla, 1968 hardback edition. This is the exact edition I read as a child, and even though I have the paperback, I just had to grab it.

Vintage 1968 hardcover book The Ghost of Windy Hill

The story follows the Carver family as they trade city life behind for a friend’s country home, whispered to be haunted. Determined to prove the ghostly rumors false, they soon discover that Windy Hill may hold more eerie secrets than they ever expected.

Goodbye Thrift Store

Hello Halloween Horrors

My favorite second-hand shop, DAV Thrift Store (last one in Kansas), recently closed – I’m so bummed. A few weeks before we said goodbye, I was casually walking through and paused in front of the large piles of albums. It was overwhelming, so I opted not to dig, thinking to myself, “If there’s a Halloween album in there, it’s going to have to jump out at me”.

At that moment, a woman behind me asked me a question. I turned back to answer her, and something caught my attention. At the front of a stack in an old milk crate (IYKYK) was a 1977 Halloween Horrors: The Sounds Of Halloween (And Other Useful Effects) LP by J. Robert Elliot.

Vintage 1977 Halloween Horrors LP

I love the cover artwork on this, and even though available wall space is shrinking, I already have a frame for it, and I look forward to getting it on display with our other albums.

Another Addams Acquisition

Drawn & Quartered

A trip to a local antique shop unearthed another addition for our haunted library: a 1964 edition of Charles Addams’ Drawn and Quartered.

1968 Vintage Charles Addams Drawn and Quartered paperback book

This paperback goes nicely with our other Addams editions, which we’ve tucked into a magazine rack in the office next to an oversized chair. The perfect pairing for when one needs to relax with a bit of macabre wit.

It’s A Frightfully Fun World

Make Some Noise

A lot of traveling took place over the past weekend, which gave us the opportunity to visit some antique shops outside our usual hunting grounds.

This vintage Halloween 1960s Fun World skeleton noisemaker horn is in very nice condition. We almost overlooked him as he was buried in a locked cabinet, and had it not been for a Beistle skeleton right up front, we would have missed him completely.

Vintage 1960s Fun World skull horn noisemaker

This piece is not uncommon or expensive, so I can’t say why we haven’t gotten one sooner, other than sometimes it’s more thrilling to find these in “the wild” than online. Regardless, he is now at home in our Cabinet of Curiosities.

Let’s Party

A Haunting Question

The final acquisition is this crepe paper party hat with a black cat medallion and a checkerboard band.

It’s in very good shape aside from a small tear along the band on one side. Very minor, considering the fragility of these items.

I was unable to find any information about this particular piece. It may not be super old, but I believe it to be at least vintage, 20-plus years old or older.

The fold of the hat is similar to other 1930s party hats, and the crepe paper looks legit. However, the checkerboard band is throwing me off, so I’m reserving judgment for now. Regardless, I love it, and it will look great tucked into our collection.

Vintage crepe paper Halloween hat

The store that offered this piece had a second one featuring a Jack O’lantern medallion, but it had a bit more damage, so we opted to leave it behind. That means it’s still out there awaiting a Halloween fanatic in search of haunted treasures to come along and give it a good home (hint, hint).

Stitch Time

Wicked Workout

All of this haunted hunting has me exhausted, so I’m going to settle in and work on stitching up those ornaments.

Until next time – stay spooky.

Free templates & patterns

130+ freebies are waiting in the Haunted Library

Templates, patterns and printables for every project on the blog.

Marsha
Your haunted host

Marsha

Counting down to Halloween since the 1970s. I create, style and celebrate all things costume and Halloween, all year round.

You May Also Like
About Me
Marsha

Hi, I’m Marsha

Welcome to my world of Halloween Ever After, where I create, style, and celebrate all things costume and Halloween.

Find Something Fun
Affiliate Disclosure

Within these haunted pages lie affiliate links to curious and captivating finds I love. If you make a purchase through them, I may earn a modest commission (think fun-size candy bar), which helps keep the Halloween magic alive. No extra cost to you – cross my batty heart.

Bearly Art Precision Craft Glue
A Making Make Believe favorite!
Buy Now
Bride and Groom Yarn Ghosts

I Do!

A Ghostly DIY

Make Me!

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Black vodka martini on a Halloween party tablescape

It's Official!

We're Haunt Friends

Check your email for the Haunted Library password.

 

Don’t miss a moment of the mischief.

Add hello@halloweeneverafter.com to your address book.

The magic happens right here in my studio and office. When you step inside my creative space, you’ll find an ever expanding gallery wall overflowing with original spooky art and classic Halloween LPs, right alongside a haunted cabinet packed to the brim with vintage curiosities.

It’s under the watchful eyes of these retro treasures that I design and craft.

We Have Room

For One More

Join us and get access to our Haunted Library stocked with templates, printables, cut files, and exclusive content. Plus, you’ll receive Eerie Emails just for our subscribers.

*Stay as long as you like. Unsubscribe at any time.