Where Halloween Lives Beyond October

Simple Ugly Christmas Sweater Hack Plus DIY Elf Shoes for Under $20

Ugly Christmas Sweater and Elf Shoe Covers
Ugly Christmas Sweater with Elf Shoe Covers

The turkey hasn’t even started to thaw for Thanksgiving, yet everywhere I turn, I see the signs of Christmas. Usually, this would provoke a “bah humbug” from me as I am not a fan of rushing from Halloween to holly days. But, given the chaos of the past couple of years, I think people just want to feel some joy. So instead of being a Grinch, I’m embracing the trend and rocking the red and green – which brings us to today’s project.

Let’s Get Ugly

Ah, the ugly Christmas sweater! You know, the one your auntie would wear to your holiday gathering. It usually featured a prominent character (or several) such as Santa or a reindeer. The design was loud – it sparkled, glittered, and jingled and was often paired with red or green tights and oversized, dangling earrings.

Crazy Christmas Auntie

Well, I hope you’re good friends with your auntie because today we’re gearing up for an Ugly Christmas Sweater Party, and you might need to borrow that tacky textile.

Ugly Rudolf Christmas Sweater

If you’re not lucky enough to have an eccentric auntie, then check out this tutorial where we transform a thrifty find. Plus, we will elevate our look by crafting a pair of elf shoe covers that might just help you win the top prize at your party. And, we’re going to do it all for under $20.

So let’s get started.

The first stop is the thrift store. My local Thrifts have holiday sweaters, sweatshirts, and other Christmas clothing items front and center. But, if yours does not, head to the clothing section and get ready to go on the hunt.

Costume Shopping At the Thrift Stop

Be On The Lookout

Any ugly Christmas sweater will do, but I tend to go with the more obnoxious.

Size isn’t an issue here. As long as the sweater is my size or larger, it’s fair game.

While I don’t pick pieces that are falling apart, I’m ok with missing bling or buttons, discoloration, or other minor issues. I can disguise those small flaws once I get the piece home.

I’m a huge advocate of thrifting costume pieces, but if you aren’t or the store’s selection is limited, you can find sweaters online at stores such as The Ugly Sweater Store and The Rusty Zipper, as well as in-store. There are also faux sweaters which, as the name implies, aren’t sweaters but are long-sleeve t-shirts with an ugly screen print to mimic the look.

Faux Real Ugly Christmas Sweater

The sweater I’m using today is one our son, Brittan, found. He likes to take a Merry Christmas pic with Lily Pug and post it to his social media every year. So this sweater is perfect since it features Lily’s likeness.

Ugly Christmas Sweater with Santa Pug

The sweater isn’t bad. However, it is missing a few bells, and the white hem and sleeve edges are dingy. These are easy fixes. I stitched the bells back onto the sweater and, while I was at it, I reinforced the remaining bells.

Ugly Christmas Sweater w Bells Fixed

There is no way to bring back the white edges, so I grabbed a white marabou boa and stitched it to the neckline, sleeve edges, and bottom hem.

Ugly Christmas Sweater Hack - Add Marabou Boa Trim
Ugly Christmas Sweater Hack - Add Marabou Boa Trim

And, just like that, this ugly Christmas sweater is ready to party.

Ugly Christmas Sweater with Santa Pug

Get Your Elf Self On

The quest for the ugliest Christmas sweater ensemble is quite competitive, so to up our game, we’re going to craft a pair of elf shoe covers. These elf shoe covers are relatively easy to make and are super inexpensive. The free SVG cut file and PDF template is available in our Haunted Library. 

We also need:

a piece of craft felt approximately 20″ by 45″ (a half a yard of 72″ craft felt will be more than enough – check the remnant section for more savings)

stuffing material

1/2 yard of 3/4″ elastic

approximately 8″-10″ of sew-on hook and loop fastener

scissors

measuring tape or ruler

chalk or marking pen

thread

pins or clips

a needle or sewing machine

embellishments as desired

A wooden dowel or chopstick will also come in handy.

Supplies for Elf Shoe Covers

Finally, you will also need the shoes you plan to wear with your shoe covers. I recommend a narrow, slip-on shoe void of laces, buckles, etc. I’m using a pair of Tom’s from my closet, but I find aqua socks are another good alternative.

Costume shoe covers are typically crafted as one-size-fits-most, but I drafted two templates to give you the greatest flexibility. Standard will work for most average-sized women’s and smaller men’s shoe sizes, while Extended has the back flaps lengthened to accommodate larger sizes.

Street Shoes To Wear Under Elf Shoe Covers

To Cut By Hand

To cut by hand, download the PDF version of the template in either the standard or extended size.

Open the PDF in Adobe Reader or your favorite PDF viewer. Select Print, and when the Print Dialog box opens, make sure the size is set to Actual Size and select Poster.

Elf Shoes PDF Print

Layout your template onto your felt and cut four of the shoe covers.

Note: If your felt has a distinctive nap, print, or design, be sure to mirror two of the pieces so that you have a left and right side for each shoe cover.

To Machine Cut

To cut with a cutting machine, download the SVG Cut File version of the template in the size you need and upload it to your design software. 

Note: If your felt has a distinctive nap, print, or design, be sure to mirror two of the pieces so that you have a left and right side for each shoe cover.

If you want to cut the pattern using your cutting machine, such as the Cricut, you will need the 24-inch cutting mat.

Put It All Together

Once you have cut all of the pieces, stack two pieces together with right sides facing out.

Begin at the top of the shoe cover, pin the pieces together, and continue to pin until you reach the base of the curled toe leaving the back and bottom open.

Then, using a 1/4″ seam allowance, stitch the pinned sections together.

Cut and Pin Elf Shoe Covers
Stitch Elf Shoe Covers

Using a wooden dowel or chopstick, take a small amount of stuffing material and work it up to the toe’s top. Be firm but gentle and take your time. It’s a tight fit, so be careful not to rip any stitches.

Continue stuffing the rest of the toe until you reach the end of the stitching, then repeat with the other shoe cover.

Stuff Toe of Elf Shoe Covers
Elf Shoe Covers with Toe Stuffed

With your shoe in the shoe cover, make a chalk mark where you want to place your elastic bands. I like to place one at the ball of my foot and one at the arch. 

We are only going to mark one side for now as we will line up the other side shortly.

Slip Street Shoe Into Elf Shoe Covers
Place Elastic and Mark at Ball of Foot
Place Elastic and Mark at Arch of Foot

In line with the mark, measure across your shoe to determine how long your elastic needs to be. Then, add 1/2″ to this measurement and cut your elastic. Repeat for the second mark.

Measure Across Ball of Foot
Measure Across Arch of Foot

Remove your shoe.

Take your shoe cover and line up the elastic with your mark. Position about 1/2″ of the elastic to the inside and pin.

Pin Elastic To Inside At Marks

Use a zigzag stitch to secure the elastic at both the ball and the arch. (I like to make two passes for extra security.)

Zigzag Stitch Elastic Onto Elf Shoe Covers
Zigzag Stitch Elastic Onto Elf Shoe Covers

Lay your shoe cover flat.

Line up the bands and mark the placement on the other side of your shoe cover. 

Next, pin the elastic bands in place and zigzag stitch to secure.

Mark Elf Shoe Cover For Elastic Placement
Pin Elastic and Stitch In Place

To close up the back, place your shoe into the shoe cover.

At the back, overlap one side onto the other and mark or note where you want to place your hook and loop closure. The back should be secure but not pulled super tight.

Quick tip: If you’re picky like me, you will want to ensure that the top piece overlaps toward the inside of the foot for a nice clean finish.

Once you decide on your placement, cut your hook and loop fastener to fit and, using a straight stitch, secure to the shoe cover.

Pin Hook and Loop To Back of Elf Shoe Covers
Stitch Hook and Loop Into Place

And – you’re done!

Once you have both shoe covers made, it’s time to take these next level by adding embellishments. Attach pom poms, bells, or tiny wrapped packages from the toe tip and add faux fur, marabou boa, or ribbons to trim the opening. Use your imagination and have fun!

Elf Shoe Covers Embellishment Supplies
Elf Shoe Covers

And now you’re all set to make a grand appearance at your Ugly Christmas Sweater Party.

Ugly Christmas Sweater and Elf Shoe Covers
Ugly Christmas Sweater and Elf Shoe Covers
Ugly Christmas Sweater and Elf Shoe Covers

So how did we spend our $20?

Not too shabby, right?

Elf Shoe Covers

I love these elf shoes. They are surprisingly easy to walk in, and I think this green pair with the red poms and white boa trim are the perfect complement to my ugly Christmas sweater. So, what do you think? Are you going to try these costume ideas? Let me know on Instagram or Facebook.

I’ve got a few other ugly ideas to share with you this season, so be sure to check back.

Until next time – keep it ugly.

Free templates & patterns

130+ freebies are waiting in the Haunted Library

Templates, patterns and printables for every project on the blog.

Marsha
Your haunted host

Marsha

Counting down to Halloween since the 1970s. I create, style and celebrate all things costume and Halloween, all year round.

You May Also Like
About Me
Marsha

Hi, I’m Marsha

Welcome to my world of Halloween Ever After, where I create, style, and celebrate all things costume and Halloween.

Find Something Fun
Affiliate Disclosure

Within these haunted pages lie affiliate links to curious and captivating finds I love. If you make a purchase through them, I may earn a modest commission (think fun-size candy bar), which helps keep the Halloween magic alive. No extra cost to you – cross my batty heart.

Bearly Art Precision Craft Glue
A Making Make Believe favorite!
Buy Now
Bride and Groom Yarn Ghosts

I Do!

A Ghostly DIY

Make Me!

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Black vodka martini on a Halloween party tablescape

It's Official!

We're Haunt Friends

Check your email for the Haunted Library password.

 

Don’t miss a moment of the mischief.

Add hello@halloweeneverafter.com to your address book.

The magic happens right here in my studio and office. When you step inside my creative space, you’ll find an ever expanding gallery wall overflowing with original spooky art and classic Halloween LPs, right alongside a haunted cabinet packed to the brim with vintage curiosities.

It’s under the watchful eyes of these retro treasures that I design and craft.

We Have Room

For One More

Join us and get access to our Haunted Library stocked with templates, printables, cut files, and exclusive content. Plus, you’ll receive Eerie Emails just for our subscribers.

*Stay as long as you like. Unsubscribe at any time.